Alliance Defending Freedom
Local Alert
📅 Tuesday, September 29, 2026 to Calendar
📄 View Official Agenda
We reviewed the upcoming agenda for Cartwright Elementary District (4282) and identified 3 items with potential legal exposure ahead of the vote.
MONITOR (LEVEL 4)
Vendor Contract Requires ‘No Boycott of Israel’ Certification
📅 September 29, 2026
The board is approving a contract with The Stepping Stones Group LLC under Consent Agenda Item E.3 that requires the vendor to certify it does not and will not ‘boycott’ Israel, pursuant to Arizona state law. This contractually-mandated certification may implicate the vendor’s First Amendment rights against compelled speech and association.
Intake Action

MONITOR: The ‘No Boycott of Israel’ clause in the vendor agreement under Item E.3 is mandated by Ariz. Rev. Stat. §§ 35-393. While this presents a First Amendment issue, the district is complying with state law. Note this as an example of the state law’s application; no direct action against the district is warranted at this time.

⚖️ Legal Hook: First Amendment – Compelled Speech
LOW (LEVEL 2)
Board Action on Adjudicated Open Meeting Law Violation
📅 September 29, 2026
Under Action Item F.1, the board is discussing and taking possible action regarding an Arizona Attorney General investigation (OML2025-0004) that found prior violations of the Open Meeting Law. The board’s proposed action is to direct its attorneys to recover funds paid under agreements deemed null and void by the AG.
Intake Action

Monitor only; no action required. The district is taking remedial action under Item F.1 on a past, adjudicated Open Meeting Law violation.

⚖️ Legal Hook: State Open Meetings Act
✅ Precedent to Preserve
Adopted language worth preserving as precedent.
Precedent (LEVEL 5)
Board to Adopt Formal Working Agreements for Governance
📅 September 29, 2026
The board will consider adopting five ‘Working Agreements’ to govern its own conduct, focusing on respect, preparation, parliamentary procedure, and staying on topic. This action formalizes norms for orderly and effective governance.
How to Preserve It

PRESERVE RECORD: The Governing Board Working Agreements under Item F.2 are a good model for board governance. Capture the adopted text from the attachment ‘9.29.26 Proposed Governing Board Working Agreements.pdf’ and file as a model policy for promoting procedural integrity.

✅ Why It Matters: Governance – Procedural Integrity
District Leadership
Address 5220 W INDIAN SCHOOL RD, PHOENIX, AZ 85031
“Contending in the courts of man, in reverence for the courts of God.”
Alliance Defending Freedom is the world’s largest legal organization committed to protecting religious freedom, free speech, the sanctity of life, parental rights, and God’s design for marriage and family.

Alliance Defending Freedom

Powered by Sentinel Engine